top of page

I Wonder How Many Versions of Me Exist in Other People's Heads

Writer: Brooke Morgan
Brooke Morgan
Oct 16
8 min read

I sometimes wonder how many completely different versions of me are walking around in other people's heads.

There's probably someone who remembers me as the girl who danced. Someone who knew me when I played the flute. Someone who remembers me as quiet, someone who thought I was funny, and someone who probably still thinks I'm the most awkward person they've ever met.

And somewhere out there, there's almost certainly someone whose entire impression of me is based on something deeply embarrassing I said when I was fourteen.

Which is unfortunate, because I would really appreciate the opportunity to appeal that decision.

The strange thing is that none of these people are necessarily wrong. They all knew me, just at different times, in different places, and under different circumstances. They each got a slightly different version of the same person, and I have absolutely no control over which one they remember.

I find that both fascinating and mildly horrifying.

Especially because, for a long time, I was very conscious of the person I was becoming around other people.

I was a lonely kid.

Not in the particularly romantic, misunderstood-protagonist sort of way. I wasn't sitting mysteriously in the corner of a classroom, reading poetry and silently judging everyone around me. I wanted friends. Quite badly, actually.

And I was willing to be a little embarrassing about it.

I think when people hear that someone used to be cringe, they imagine a very specific kind of person. Loud, attention-seeking, constantly trying to be the centre of everything.

I was almost the opposite.

My particular brand of embarrassing was much quieter.

I was the girl who wanted so badly to be included that I became remarkably good at figuring out what other people liked and adjusting myself accordingly.

If someone had a certain sense of humour, I learned it. If they were interested in something, suddenly I was interested too. If a group behaved a particular way, I tried to behave that way.

I became a sort of unofficial student of other people's personalities.

And I was very dedicated to my studies.

I don't think I was consciously pretending to be somebody else. At least, not in the way that sounds. It was more instinctive than that. I would notice which parts of me seemed to go over well and which ones didn't, and I'd make adjustments.

A little less of this. A little more of that.

Like I was constantly editing a document nobody had actually asked me to submit.

The funny thing is that I had plenty of interests of my own. I danced, played music, experimented with producing songs, modeled, and spent various periods of my life enthusiastically convinced that whatever I was doing at the time was going to become my entire personality.

I wasn't lacking things to say or do.

I just wasn't particularly confident that the things I genuinely liked, or the person I naturally was, would be enough to make other people want to know me.

And I think there's an important difference between those two things.

Having lots of interests doesn't necessarily mean you know how to be yourself around people.

You can have an entire world going on inside your head and still feel completely unsure of how to exist in a room full of other people.

For me, being liked sometimes felt like a problem I could solve if I paid close enough attention.

Surely there was a correct way to be funny. A correct way to respond to things. A correct amount of enthusiasm to show without becoming annoying.

If I could just figure out the formula, everything would fall into place.

Which, looking back, is a fairly exhausting way to approach friendship.

It's also a little sad.

I can laugh about it now, and I do, but I don't think I realized at the time how much energy I was spending trying to make myself acceptable.

There's something particularly lonely about being surrounded by people and still feeling like you have to earn your place among them.

And there's something even lonelier about wondering whether people would still like you if you stopped trying so hard.

I think that's why the idea of existing differently in other people's memories interests me so much.

Because I know some people remember versions of me that I deliberately constructed.

Not entirely fake versions. I don't think it's that simple. But versions that were carefully adjusted to fit the people around me.

There are probably people who remember me as someone who loved things I was only mildly interested in. People who thought I was much quieter than I actually was. People who knew me during periods when I was so concerned with being agreeable that I barely expressed an opinion.

And there are probably people who thought I was strange anyway.

Which feels a little rude, considering all the effort.

But I also wonder how much of this is just part of growing up.

We're constantly told to be ourselves, usually by adults who seem to have forgotten how genuinely difficult that can be when you're young.

Because who exactly is yourself at thirteen?

Or fifteen?

Or even twenty?

I don't think identity is some fully formed thing we're born with and spend our lives trying to uncover. I think it's something we develop through experience, through other people, through the things we try and abandon and return to years later.

And sometimes through being absolutely unbearable for a little while.

I certainly wouldn't want to be the exact person I was at fourteen.

I don't even particularly want to defend her.

But I do feel a certain affection for her now.

She was trying.

Maybe a little too hard, and often in entirely the wrong directions, but she was trying to find somewhere she belonged.

And I think it's easy to look back at younger versions of ourselves with embarrassment because we have the advantage of knowing what happened next.

We know which friendships lasted. We know which problems turned out to be insignificant. We know that the thing we were absolutely convinced would ruin our lives was, in fact, barely worth mentioning.

But the person experiencing those things didn't know any of that.

To her, it mattered.

And I think she deserves a little credit for getting through it.

What I find especially strange is how different my life feels now.

University has been one of the most unexpectedly wonderful experiences of my life, and I think a huge part of that has been the people I've met.

For the first time, I've found myself surrounded by friends who genuinely appreciate the things about me I once thought I needed to tone down.

I can be loud. I can be opinionated. I can make ridiculous jokes, get overly invested in completely insignificant conversations, and occasionally say something that sounded considerably better in my head.

And nobody seems particularly concerned.

In fact, some people appear to enjoy it.

A rather revolutionary development.

I don't spend nearly as much time wondering whether I'm behaving correctly. I don't leave every conversation mentally reviewing everything I said, trying to work out whether I came across as strange or annoying.

And when I do catch myself overthinking, which still happens because apparently some habits are determined to stick around, I find it much easier to recognize what I'm doing.

I don't need to become a slightly different person every time I meet somebody new.

I can just meet them.

It's such a simple thing, but I don't think I understood how freeing it could be until I experienced it.

And I think that's part of why I've had so much fun in university.

I'm not constantly auditioning for a place in somebody else's life anymore.

I'm actually enjoying my own.

There's something wonderful about realizing that the things you once considered your social disadvantages might be exactly what the right people appreciate about you.

The loudness. The enthusiasm. The strong opinions. The tendency to find something funny at an entirely inappropriate moment.

I used to think these were things I needed to manage.

Now they're just things about me.

And I like them.

I think being lonely when I was younger also made me much more independent than I realized at the time.

When you spend a lot of time feeling like you don't quite belong, you eventually learn how to exist on your own. You develop interests that don't depend on other people sharing them. You learn how to entertain yourself, how to make decisions, and how to keep going even when things feel a little uncomfortable.

I wouldn't necessarily recommend loneliness as a character-building exercise. There are probably more enjoyable methods.

But I can't pretend it didn't shape me.

I think a lot of my confidence now comes from having spent so much time without it.

I know what it's like to feel unsure of myself, to want desperately to be included, to wonder whether there's something fundamentally unlikeable about the person I am.

And I also know that I got through all of that.

There's a certain strength that comes from realizing you no longer need the approval you once worked so hard to get.

Not because you stop caring about other people, but because you stop treating their opinions as the final authority on who you are.

Which brings me back to all those different versions of myself.

I sometimes wonder what the people who knew me when I was younger would think if they met me now.

Would they recognize me?

Would they be surprised by how much I've changed? Would they think I was louder, more confident, more comfortable in my own skin?

Or would they think I was exactly the same?

I suppose that's the strange thing about memory. We don't just remember people. We preserve them.

Somewhere, I'm still the girl who was trying too hard to make friends. Somewhere else, I'm the girl who danced, the girl who played music, the girl who barely spoke, or the girl who wouldn't stop talking.

Those versions of me are probably going to exist for as long as somebody remembers them.

Even though I've moved on.

And I used to find that idea unsettling.

The thought that someone could have an entirely inaccurate impression of me, and that I might never get the chance to correct it, would once have bothered me enormously.

I wanted to be understood. I wanted people to know that I was funny, interesting, kind, worth being friends with.

I wanted to make sure nobody got the wrong idea.

Now, I find myself caring a lot less.

Not because I've become indifferent to what people think, but because I've realized that being understood by absolutely everyone is an impossible ambition.

People only know what they've seen. They interpret things through their own experiences, their own insecurities, their own memories. Two people can know you at exactly the same time and still come away with completely different ideas of who you are.

And neither of those ideas necessarily has to define you.

Maybe somebody remembers me as awkward.

Maybe somebody remembers me as confident.

Maybe somebody remembers me as the girl who tried too hard, while someone else remembers me as the girl who never seemed to care what anybody thought.

They're all entitled to their memories.

I don't need to go around updating everyone on the latest version.

I think that's one of the nicest things about getting older. You slowly stop feeling obligated to explain yourself to people who only knew you for a chapter.

And you start paying more attention to the people who are actually here for the rest of the story.

The people I've met in university don't necessarily know every version of me that came before this one. They don't know every embarrassing phase, every awkward conversation, every friendship I tried desperately to make work.

But they know me now.

And, rather wonderfully, they seem to like me.

Not a carefully edited version. Not a personality assembled from whatever I think will go over best.

Just me.

Which is funny, considering how much time I spent believing that wouldn't be enough.

There are probably hundreds of versions of me scattered across other people's memories.

Some I'd recognize. Some I'd cringe at. Some I'd probably insist were wildly inaccurate.

And maybe none of them has the complete picture.

But for the first time, I don't feel particularly compelled to find out.

I spent a long time worrying about who I was in other people's stories.

It's been rather nice to finally get interested in my own.


Comments


bottom of page