I Wouldn't Survive a Week in Tudor England, and I'm Obsessed With It

I have an almost unreasonable obsession with medieval and Tudor England, which is particularly strange considering I would probably last about four days if somebody actually sent me there.
I love the castles, the clothes, the court politics, the religious scandals, the marriages arranged for political advantage, and the fact that seemingly every prominent family was related to every other prominent family in some increasingly complicated way. I could spend hours reading about the Tudors and still find some obscure relative, disputed pregnancy, or centuries-old rumour to become completely consumed by.
And yet, the more I learn about this period, the less I can understand why anyone would actually want to live through it.
I think we've developed a remarkably romantic understanding of medieval and early modern Europe. We imagine candlelit banquets, elaborate dresses, enormous stone castles, and beautiful women looking wistfully out of windows while their husbands are away at war. There are tapestries on the walls, horses in the courtyards, and apparently everybody is either a princess or hopelessly in love with one.
What we tend to leave out is the smell.
And the disease. And the parasites. And the very real possibility of dying from something that could be treated with a trip to the pharmacy today.
To be clear, I'm talking specifically about England and parts of medieval and early modern Europe. I don't think it's particularly accurate to describe the entire world during this period as primitive. China, for example, had sophisticated urban infrastructure, printing technologies, extensive commercial networks, and medical traditions that developed over centuries. Across Asia, different societies were making significant advances in mathematics, engineering, astronomy, and administration. Europe was neither the centre of every intellectual development nor uniformly backward.
And even within Europe, the picture is more complicated than the popular idea of the filthy, ignorant Middle Ages. Medieval people bathed, cities had systems for managing waste, and universities and medical institutions existed. The problem is that none of this made life remotely as comfortable or medically safe as the version we encounter in historical dramas.
I can appreciate that distinction and still be fairly certain that the conditions in a sixteenth-century English town would send me into a complete psychological crisis.
The lack of modern sanitation alone would be enough. Add recurring epidemics, dangerous childbirth, limited medical treatments, and the constant possibility of political or religious upheaval, and suddenly the appeal of wearing a beautiful velvet gown becomes considerably less convincing.
And yet I remain obsessed.
Particularly with the Tudors.
I genuinely think the history of Henry VIII, Anne Boleyn, and Elizabeth I is more fascinating than almost anything a television writer could invent. The fact that these were actual people, making actual decisions that would alter the religious and political structure of England, makes their story infinitely more compelling to me.
And I think Anne Boleyn might be one of the most interesting women in English history.
What fascinates me most about Anne is how completely her reputation has been shaped by the people who wanted something from her.
To Henry VIII, she became the woman he was willing to overturn the established religious order of his kingdom to marry. To her enemies, she was ambitious, manipulative, sexually dangerous, and responsible for the destruction of a legitimate queen's marriage. To later generations, she became a tragic heroine, a Protestant martyr, a feminist icon, or some combination of all three.
I sometimes wonder how much of the actual Anne Boleyn survives beneath all those interpretations.
She wasn't born expecting to become queen. She was the daughter of Thomas Boleyn and Elizabeth Howard, educated partly in the courts of the Low Countries and France, and later became a lady-in-waiting to Catherine of Aragon, Henry's first wife.
I find that detail particularly fascinating. Before Anne became the woman who displaced Catherine, she served in her household.
It's almost impossible to imagine how complicated those relationships must have become once Henry began pursuing her.
And Henry did pursue her. For years.
His surviving love letters are extraordinary, particularly when you remember who wrote them. Here was a king accustomed to having his wishes obeyed, expressing his frustration and desire toward a woman who did not simply become his mistress.
I think people sometimes underestimate how unusual Anne's position was. Henry had previously taken mistresses, including Anne's own sister Mary, although the exact details of Mary's relationship with him remain uncertain. Anne, however, resisted becoming another woman whose relationship with the king could end whenever his interest faded.
Whether her refusal was driven by personal conviction, calculation, family ambition, or some combination of those things is impossible to know. What matters is that the relationship developed into something with enormous political consequences.
Henry was already desperate for a legitimate male heir. Catherine of Aragon had given birth to several children, but only their daughter Mary survived into adulthood. Henry increasingly argued that his marriage to Catherine was invalid because she had previously been married to his older brother Arthur.
And Anne became inseparable from his determination to secure an annulment.
I think the way we romanticize Henry and Anne's relationship is particularly revealing.
On the surface, it contains almost everything a historical romance could want. A powerful king becomes obsessed with a woman he cannot easily have. He writes passionate letters, defies established authority, and risks his relationship with Rome to make her his queen.
Except the actual story is considerably uglier.
Catherine of Aragon was publicly humiliated, removed from her position, and separated from her daughter. Mary was declared illegitimate. England underwent a religious and political transformation that cannot be reduced to Henry's desire for Anne, although that desire was a major catalyst.
And Anne, the woman for whom Henry had apparently been willing to do all of this, would eventually be executed on his orders.
It's difficult to imagine a more horrifying demonstration of how quickly royal affection could become royal hostility.
Henry and Anne married in 1533, and Anne gave birth to Elizabeth that September.
Not a son.
I always find myself thinking about how differently that birth must have been experienced by everyone involved.
Today, Elizabeth I is one of the most recognizable monarchs in English history. We know what she became. We know about the Elizabethan settlement, the defeat of the Spanish Armada, and the extraordinary cultural achievements associated with her reign.
But in September 1533, she was simply another daughter born to a king who desperately wanted a son.
Anne had been elevated to the throne under enormous pressure to produce the male heir Catherine had failed to provide. Her political security depended heavily on something she could not control.
And when she failed to produce a surviving son, her position became increasingly precarious.
I think that's one of the cruelest aspects of Tudor history. Women could be blamed for the sex of their children, for miscarriages, for infertility, and for circumstances over which they had no meaningful power.
Henry's obsession with securing his dynasty made the women around him responsible for solving a problem that was ultimately biological, political, and deeply personal to him.
By 1536, Anne had suffered further pregnancy losses, Henry's attention had turned toward Jane Seymour, and Anne's enemies had opportunities to move against her.
Then came the accusations.
Adultery. Incest with her brother George Boleyn. Conspiracy against the king.
The charges were extraordinary, and historians have long questioned their credibility. The evidence presented against Anne was deeply problematic, and many historians regard her conviction as a politically motivated miscarriage of justice.
Five men, including her brother, were executed in connection with the accusations. Anne herself was executed at the Tower of London on 19 May 1536.
Henry had arranged for a skilled swordsman from Calais to carry out the execution.
I have always found that detail particularly disturbing.
There is something almost grotesque about the care taken to provide a supposedly more merciful death to a woman whose destruction the king had permitted. The arrangements suggest a strange concern with dignity at the very moment her life was being taken away.
Anne was around thirty-five years old, although her exact birth year remains disputed.
Her daughter Elizabeth was two.
And eleven days later, Henry married Jane Seymour.
I don't think there's any way to romanticize that sequence of events without deliberately ignoring what happened.
The king who had once written Anne passionate letters, who had spent years attempting to make her his wife, was married to another woman less than two weeks after her execution.
And the daughter Anne left behind was declared illegitimate.
This is where the story becomes particularly fascinating to me, because Henry VIII spent so much of his reign trying to control the future of his dynasty, and the future ultimately belonged to the daughter of the woman he had destroyed.
Elizabeth I.
I know it's historically simplistic to describe Elizabeth's reign as revenge for Anne Boleyn. Elizabeth never publicly framed her rule that way, and we have no reliable evidence that she governed with the intention of avenging her mother.
But I cannot help finding something deeply satisfying about the irony.
Henry had six wives. He spent decades attempting to secure a stable male succession. His marriage to Anne helped precipitate England's break with papal authority. His determination to produce a son contributed to the suffering of multiple women, including two who were executed.
And one of the most celebrated rulers to emerge from the Tudor dynasty was Anne's daughter.
The little girl whose birth had been a disappointment.
The daughter who had been declared illegitimate.
The child who grew up knowing that her father had ordered her mother's execution.
I wonder what Elizabeth thought about Anne.
We have frustratingly little direct evidence of Elizabeth's private feelings toward her mother. She was so young when Anne died that she probably had few, if any, clear memories of her.
And she grew up in a political environment where speaking openly about Anne could be dangerous.
But there are small details that I find incredibly moving.
One of my favourites is the famous Chequers Ring, associated with Elizabeth and traditionally understood to contain miniature portraits of herself and a woman often identified as Anne Boleyn. The identification isn't completely certain, but the possibility that Elizabeth carried an image of her mother in such a private object is extraordinary.
I also love the fact that Elizabeth maintained relationships with members of the Boleyn family, including relatives connected to her mother's household.
Anne was never entirely erased from her daughter's life, even though the circumstances of her death made her memory politically complicated.
And then there's Elizabeth's decision never to marry.
I think this is one of the most fascinating aspects of her reign, although I don't believe it can be explained simply by saying that she was traumatized by what happened to her mother.
Elizabeth had countless political reasons to remain unmarried. Marriage could have compromised her independence, empowered a foreign ruler, or created dangerous factions within her court. Her unmarried status also became a remarkably effective part of her political identity.
But I find it difficult not to think about the examples of marriage she had witnessed.
Her mother had been executed by her husband. Her stepmother Catherine Howard was also executed. Her father's marriages repeatedly demonstrated how vulnerable even queens could be when their security depended on royal favour.
Elizabeth understood better than almost anyone that marriage, particularly for a woman with political power, could be extraordinarily dangerous.
And she found a way to rule without surrendering that power to a husband.
I don't think we can know exactly how much her family history influenced that decision. But it's difficult to imagine that it meant nothing.
Elizabeth became queen in 1558, following the death of her half-sister Mary I.
Her reign lasted more than forty-four years.
She inherited a kingdom deeply divided by the religious changes of the preceding decades and developed a religious settlement that helped establish the Church of England's enduring position, although religious conflict certainly did not disappear.
She survived plots against her, navigated complicated relationships with European powers, and presided over the defeat of the Spanish Armada in 1588.
Her reign also became associated with an extraordinary period of English literary and theatrical culture, including the work of Shakespeare and Marlowe, even as England's involvement in colonial expansion and violence complicates any uncomplicated celebration of the Elizabethan age.
And she did all of this without marrying.
I find the symbolism almost too perfect.
Henry had been so consumed by the idea that his dynasty required a male heir, and yet his daughters Mary and Elizabeth both ruled England. His only legitimate son, Edward VI, died at fifteen after a reign of just over six years.
Elizabeth would reign longer than Henry's three children combined.
I sometimes think about what Anne Boleyn would have made of that.
Would she have been proud? Relieved? Astonished that the daughter whose birth had failed to secure her position would become such a formidable monarch?
I know those questions are impossible to answer, but I find them irresistible.
There's a temptation to imagine Anne somehow vindicated through Elizabeth, as though her daughter's achievements could retrospectively correct the injustice of her execution.
Of course they couldn't.
Anne never saw Elizabeth grow up. She never knew the woman her daughter became. Whatever satisfaction we find in the historical irony belongs to us, not to her.
And I think that's what makes it so bittersweet.
Elizabeth's reign didn't undo what happened to Anne. It simply ensured that the woman Henry had discarded would remain inseparable from the story of the dynasty he had been so desperate to preserve.
In a sense, Anne Boleyn became far more historically significant than Henry could ever have anticipated.
Not simply because of the religious upheaval surrounding their marriage, but because of the daughter she left behind.
I think that's the part of Tudor history that has always fascinated me most. These people were making decisions based on the immediate political anxieties of their own lives, completely unaware of how history would eventually remember them.
Henry believed he was securing the future of his dynasty. Anne believed, or at least hoped, that becoming queen would secure her own position. Elizabeth grew up in the shadow of decisions made before she was old enough to understand them.
And centuries later, we're still arguing about what they wanted, what they believed, and how much of their behaviour was driven by love, ambition, fear, or survival.
I love that history can be so intimate.
We talk about monarchs as political figures, but their decisions were often shaped by recognizably human emotions. Jealousy, insecurity, resentment, desire. The difference was that their personal conflicts could become national crises.
An ordinary marriage falling apart is painful enough. When the husband is Henry VIII, it can contribute to the restructuring of an entire country's religious institutions.
And this is precisely why I find the romanticization of Tudor England so interesting.
We look back at the portraits, the palaces, the elaborate clothing, and the dramatic love stories, and we create this beautiful image of a period that was frequently brutal to the people who actually lived through it.
Anne Boleyn's gowns were magnificent. Hampton Court Palace is extraordinary. The surviving portraits of Elizabeth I are some of the most fascinating images of royal power ever produced.
But the beauty of the period existed alongside religious persecution, executions, disease, and a society in which a woman's position could be destroyed by the failure to produce a male child.
I think it's possible to be completely enchanted by the aesthetics of a historical period while recognizing that the reality would have been deeply unpleasant.
In fact, I think the contradiction is part of what makes it so fascinating.
I can spend hours looking at Tudor portraits, reading about the women at Henry's court, or trying to untangle the political alliances surrounding Anne Boleyn's downfall. I can appreciate the architecture and the clothing, and I can understand why people are so drawn to historical dramas that make the period look impossibly beautiful.
But I don't want to live there.
I want to read about it from the comfort of a room with central heating, modern plumbing, and access to antibiotics.
Preferably while wearing something considerably less restrictive than a sixteenth-century court gown.
And I think that's a perfectly reasonable way to enjoy history.
I'm fascinated by the Tudors precisely because their world was so different from mine, and because the people who inhabited it were still recognizably human. They were capable of extraordinary cruelty, astonishing ambition, and the same irrational attachments that shape people's lives today.
I just happen to think their particular combination of family drama and political catastrophe is almost impossible to beat.
Especially when you remember how the story of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn ended.
A king spent years pursuing a woman, overturned the established religious order of his kingdom to marry her, and eventually ordered her execution when their marriage no longer served his purposes.
He wanted a son who would secure his legacy.
Instead, history gave him Elizabeth.
And I think Anne would have liked that.

Comments