top of page

Somewhere, Merrilee Donner Grew Old for Both of Them

Writer: Brooke Morgan
Brooke Morgan
Oct 16
6 min read

I've been thinking about Sunrise on the Reaping again, which is becoming something of a problem considering the movie isn't even out yet.

And while I'm obviously excited to see Haymitch's Games brought to life- the casting, the arena, and what is shaping up to be a remarkably faithful adaptation of Suzanne Collins's novel- there's one detail I keep coming back to.

Merrilee Donner had to grow up looking like her dead sister.

I genuinely don't think I've recovered from that realization.

For anyone who hasn't read the book, Maysilee Donner is one of the District 12 tributes selected for the Fiftieth Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, where twice the usual number of children are sent into the arena. She's sixteen, she's sharp-tongued, she's privileged by District 12 standards, and she's initially not the easiest person to like.

She also has an identical twin sister, Merrilee, who doesn't get reaped.

And I think we all know where this is going.

One of the things Suzanne Collins does exceptionally well is remind us that the Hunger Games don't end when the cameras turn off. The arena is where the violence happens, but the consequences belong to everyone who has to keep living afterward.

And in Merrilee's case, I can't imagine a more haunting version of that.

Because think about it.

Merrilee would have watched herself turn seventeen, eighteen, twenty, thirty. She would have watched her face mature, her features change, her hair perhaps begin to grey. She would have experienced every ordinary milestone that Maysilee never got to reach.

And every time she looked in the mirror, she would have seen some version of the person her sister might have become.

That's an almost unbearable thought.

Most people who lose someone have photographs. They have memories of what that person looked like, how they smiled, the expressions they made when they were annoyed. Eventually, those images become fixed in time. The person stays the same age in every picture while the rest of the world continues moving.

But Merrilee had something much stranger.

She had her own reflection.

Of course, identical twins aren't identical in every possible way, and growing older doesn't mean Merrilee would have known exactly what Maysilee would have looked like. But she would have carried the closest thing imaginable to a living resemblance of her sister.

And I wonder whether that would have been comforting or absolutely devastating.

Probably both.

Imagine turning twenty-five and wondering whether Maysilee would have worn her hair the same way. Imagine noticing a new line beside your eyes and realizing your sister never got old enough to have one. Imagine being forty and remembering that the last time you saw her, she was still a teenager.

Imagine looking into the mirror and realizing that the person looking back at you is someone your sister never had the chance to become.

It's the kind of grief that doesn't even allow you the luxury of forgetting for a moment.

And this is why I find Collins's writing so much more upsetting than people sometimes give it credit for.

We talk about The Hunger Games as a dystopian series, and obviously it is. There are elaborate arenas, political rebellions, government propaganda, and enough horrifying deaths to make you wonder why any of us were reading these books at twelve years old.

But I don't think the most disturbing part of Panem is the spectacle.

I think it's the ordinary lives that are interrupted.

It's the birthdays that still happen. The empty seats at dinner. The families who have to keep going to work. The people who become adults while someone they loved remains permanently sixteen.

The Capitol doesn't just kill children. It steals all the versions of them that might have existed.

And the people left behind have to live with that absence.

That's what makes Maysilee's story particularly heartbreaking to me. She isn't simply another tribute whose death contributes to Haymitch's trauma. She's somebody's twin sister. Somebody who had a life running parallel to her own until the Capitol decided that only one of them would be allowed to continue it.

There's a moment in the novel when Maysilee wonders whether Merrilee will still be a twin after she's gone.

And I think that's one of the saddest questions Collins has ever written.

Because what does it mean to be a twin when the other half of that relationship is no longer there?

Merrilee doesn't stop being Maysilee's sister when Maysilee dies. She doesn't suddenly become an only child. But the person who made that particular part of her identity possible is gone.

She's still a twin.

She's just a twin alone.

I don't know how you write something like that and then expect readers to continue with their day.

Which brings me to the movie.

There's been a lot of conversation about how closely Sunrise on the Reaping appears to be following the book, and I have to say, I'm cautiously optimistic.

Book adaptations are always a slightly dangerous business. Everyone wants their favourite novel brought to life until somebody changes a character's personality, removes a beloved scene, or decides that a perfectly good plot needs an entirely new romantic subplot.

Suddenly we're all film critics.

But with Sunrise on the Reaping, the attention being paid to smaller character details is what interests me most.

Mckenna Grace, who plays Maysilee, has discussed pushing to preserve details from the novel, including Maysilee's braid and the pins associated with the Donner sisters. And I love that.

Not because every accessory needs to survive the transition from page to screen, but because those details mean something.

The mockingjay pin, in particular, is such an extraordinary example of how Collins connects the lives of people across generations.

Long before Katniss Everdeen becomes the Mockingjay, Maysilee Donner has a connection to the very symbol that will eventually come to represent rebellion.

A girl who doesn't survive her own Games becomes part of the history of a revolution she will never witness.

There's something both beautiful and infuriating about that.

And it makes me think about how many people in The Hunger Games never get to know what their lives meant to the people who came after them.

Maysilee never gets to see the rebellion. She never gets to know Katniss. She never gets to grow up alongside Merrilee.

But her story doesn't disappear.

It survives in objects, memories, relationships, and the people who remember her.

I think that's why book accuracy matters so much with this particular adaptation.

Not because I need every conversation reproduced word for word, or because I think changing anything from the source material is automatically a crime against literature.

Sometimes films need to make changes. A novel and a movie are different forms of storytelling, and pretending otherwise doesn't help either of them.

But I do think there's a difference between changing the way a story is told and changing what makes it meaningful.

And with Collins, meaning is so often hiding in the details.

A piece of jewellery. A familiar song. A name. A sister left standing in a crowd.

Things that seem small until you realize they're carrying an entire history of grief.

I hope the film understands that.

I hope Maysilee is given enough time to become a person rather than simply another tragic moment in Haymitch's story. I hope we see her personality, her stubbornness, her relationship with her sister, and the ordinary teenage girl beneath the spectacle the Capitol has created around her.

Because the tragedy isn't just that Maysilee dies.

It's that she should have lived.

She should have gotten older. She should have had arguments with Merrilee about completely insignificant things. She should have had birthdays, bad haircuts, favourite songs, embarrassing crushes, and an entire lifetime of experiences that had absolutely nothing to do with the Capitol.

She should have been allowed to become someone we never got to meet.

And Merrilee should have been beside her for all of it.

Instead, one sister remains sixteen, and the other has to carry on growing older.

I keep thinking about Merrilee as an old woman.

About whether she ever caught herself making an expression that reminded her of Maysilee. Whether she ever wondered if they would have looked alike at seventy. Whether, after decades of living without her sister, she still occasionally turned to tell her something.

There's no way to know, of course.

And perhaps that's the most upsetting part.

Collins gives us just enough of these lives to understand how much has been taken, then leaves us to imagine everything that might have happened afterward.

So yes, I'm excited for Sunrise on the Reaping. I'm excited about the cast, the adaptation, and the possibility of seeing one of the most devastating stories in the series translated faithfully to the screen.

But I already know which part is going to stay with me.

Not the arena. Not the spectacle. Not even the outcome of Haymitch's Games.

Just the thought of a woman growing old with a face that might have belonged to her sister, too.

And the awful realization that, somewhere along the way, Merrilee Donner became older than Maysilee would ever be.

Comments


bottom of page