top of page

The Girls We Never Really Knew

Writer: Brooke Morgan
Brooke Morgan
Nov 1
7 min read

There is something unsettling about the way we remember people we never really knew. We fill in the gaps of their personalities with our own assumptions, assigning meaning to their actions based on what little we were able to observe. Eventually, the version of someone we have constructed in our minds can become so convincing that we forget how much of it was invented in the first place.

I think Jeffrey Eugenides' The Virgin Suicides captures this particularly well.

The novel follows the five Lisbon sisters, whose lives and deaths are reconstructed through the collective memories of a group of neighbourhood boys. Years after the sisters' deaths, the boys remain preoccupied with understanding what happened, collecting objects associated with them and revisiting memories that might offer some explanation.

Yet despite all this attention, the girls remain strangely unknowable.

We learn about their appearances and the impressions they leave on the people around them. We learn how the boys feel about them, what they imagine their lives must have been like, and how profoundly their deaths affect the neighbourhood. But we learn remarkably little about who the sisters actually were.

I think this absence is one of the most important aspects of the novel, particularly because it forces us to consider how easily fascination can be mistaken for understanding.

The Difference Between Looking and Understanding

Throughout The Virgin Suicides, the Lisbon sisters are constantly being observed.

The boys watch them from across the street and speculate about their private lives, interpreting even their smallest gestures as though they might contain some hidden meaning. Their fascination gradually becomes a kind of investigation, with personal possessions and fragments of conversations treated as potential evidence.

What interests me is how easily observation becomes confused with intimacy.

The boys know what the sisters look like. They remember what they wore and how they behaved in particular moments. They can describe details of the Lisbon household that seem almost insignificant, yet none of this knowledge necessarily brings them any closer to understanding the girls' experiences.

There is a difference between knowing things about someone and actually knowing them, and the boys seem largely unable to recognize it.

Their fascination is often presented through the language of affection and concern, but I think it also reveals a certain entitlement to the sisters' private lives. The girls become mysteries that the boys believe they should be able to solve, as though their inability to understand them is a problem that must eventually have an explanation.

Rather than accepting that the sisters might possess experiences beyond their understanding, the boys continue searching for an interpretation that will make everything fit together.

In doing so, they reveal considerably more about themselves than they ever do about the Lisbon sisters.

The Problem with Making Someone a Mystery

I find it particularly interesting that the Lisbon sisters become more fascinating to the boys precisely because they are inaccessible.

Their increasingly restricted lives make them difficult to understand, but this distance seems to intensify the boys' interest. The sisters gradually become almost mythical figures within the neighbourhood, surrounded by interpretations that have very little to do with their actual personalities.

I think there is something familiar about this tendency to romanticize people we cannot fully understand. When we know very little about someone, it becomes easier to imagine them as possessing qualities we find interesting or desirable. Their absence from our lives leaves considerable room for us to construct an identity on their behalf.

In The Virgin Suicides, the boys' fascination depends partly on this uncertainty. The Lisbon sisters can remain extraordinary because the boys never have to confront the ordinary realities of who they might have been.

What I find particularly sad is how frequently the sisters are understood as a collective, almost as though their shared circumstances make them interchangeable. Although Eugenides provides glimpses of their individual personalities, the boys' memories tend to preserve the sisters as a single object of fascination.

This becomes especially significant when we consider that the boys' obsession continues long after the girls have died. Their memories preserve an idealized version of the sisters, but that preservation does very little to recover the individuality that was overlooked while they were alive.

The boys seem so concerned with understanding what the Lisbon sisters represented that they never quite manage to understand them as people.

When Tragedy Becomes Beautiful

One of the most uncomfortable aspects of The Virgin Suicides is the way its tragedy becomes almost inseparable from its beauty.

The novel's nostalgic atmosphere makes the Lisbon sisters' world feel strangely dreamlike, while Sofia Coppola's film adaptation develops this effect through its visual style and soundtrack. There is something undeniably captivating about the way the story is presented, even when we are fully aware of what happens to the girls.

But I think this beauty also creates a problem worth considering.

When suffering is presented through such an appealing aesthetic, it becomes easy to admire the atmosphere surrounding a tragedy without fully confronting the experiences of the people involved.

The Lisbon sisters have become associated with a particular image of adolescent femininity, one that emphasizes melancholy and a kind of delicate vulnerability. Their suffering is incorporated into an aesthetic that can be appreciated independently of the circumstances that produced it.

I find this especially interesting because it reflects the way the boys themselves approach the sisters. Their fascination is sustained by the mystery surrounding the girls, and even after their deaths, they continue to interpret their lives through the same romanticized perspective.

The tragedy becomes part of what makes the sisters extraordinary in their memories.

I don't think this necessarily means that Eugenides or Coppola are attempting to romanticize suicide. In fact, I would argue that the discomfort produced by this aesthetic is part of what makes the story so effective. We are encouraged to recognize the beauty of the boys' memories while also questioning the perspective through which those memories have been constructed.

Still, I think it is worth considering how easily representations of female suffering can become detached from the women experiencing it, particularly when their pain is presented in a way that audiences find visually or emotionally appealing.

Who Gets to Tell the Story?

Perhaps the most interesting decision Eugenides makes is allowing the boys to narrate the novel.

The Lisbon sisters are at the centre of the story, but they are not the ones telling it. Everything we know about them has been filtered through the memories of people who were never particularly close to them.

This creates an interesting imbalance in the relationship between the subjects of the story and those responsible for telling it.

The boys have the ability to preserve the sisters' lives through their recollections, but they also determine how those lives are represented. Because the sisters are no longer alive to challenge these interpretations, the boys' version becomes the primary account available to us.

I think this raises an important question about how much authority we should have over the stories of other people, particularly when our understanding of their experiences is so limited.

The boys seem genuinely affected by the sisters' deaths, and their continued attempts to understand what happened suggest that their fascination is not entirely superficial. However, I find it difficult to ignore how their investigation also allows them to maintain a sense of ownership over the girls' experiences.

Even in death, the sisters remain subjects of observation.

The boys continue to search for explanations, seemingly convinced that the right piece of information might finally allow them to understand the girls completely. Yet the novel repeatedly demonstrates the limitations of this approach.

There are aspects of another person's life that cannot be recovered through observation, regardless of how carefully their behaviour is examined.

I think the boys struggle to accept this because doing so would require them to acknowledge that the Lisbon sisters existed beyond the versions of them they had created.

The Girls Behind the Story

I don't think The Virgin Suicides is ultimately a novel about discovering why the Lisbon sisters died. If anything, I think Eugenides uses the boys' desire for an explanation to expose how uncomfortable we are with the possibility that another person's experiences might remain beyond our understanding.

The boys spend years searching for answers, convinced that some overlooked detail might finally explain what happened. But the novel never provides the kind of resolution they seem to want, and I think that uncertainty is essential to its meaning.

There is something troubling about the assumption that another person's suffering must eventually become understandable to us. We often approach tragedy with the expectation that it should have an explanation, as though identifying the right circumstances could somehow make an experience comprehensible.

But the Lisbon sisters' lives cannot be reduced to the boys' attempts to interpret them.

What stays with me most is the possibility that the girls were never quite the extraordinary figures the boys imagined them to be. They were young women whose experiences were far more complicated than the people around them were willing or able to recognize.

Although the novel offers occasional glimpses of their personalities, much of their inner lives remains inaccessible. We are left to understand them through the memories of people whose fascination may have prevented them from seeing the sisters clearly in the first place.

I think this is what makes the novel so unsettling. The boys dedicate an extraordinary amount of time to remembering the Lisbon sisters, yet their devotion does not necessarily bring them any closer to understanding who the girls were.

Their memories tell us a great deal about the way the sisters were perceived, particularly about the expectations and fantasies projected onto them.

But the girls themselves remain largely absent from the story being told about their lives.

And perhaps that is the most significant limitation of the boys' narration. They have spent years trying to explain the Lisbon sisters, without ever fully considering how much of their understanding was shaped by their own desire to make the girls into something extraordinary.

Comments


bottom of page