top of page

The Problem With Wanting to Be Understood

Writer: Brooke Morgan
Brooke Morgan
Oct 16
4 min read

I think there’s something a little embarrassing about how badly we all want to be understood.

Not liked, necessarily. Not even agreed with. Just understood. As in, someone could look at the entire mess of things going on in your head and say, Oh, I see what you mean.

Which, when you think about it, is a pretty unreasonable thing to expect from another person. Half the time I don’t even know what I mean.

But I think that’s partly why I love literature so much. It’s one of the few places where we’re allowed to know someone completely, or at least believe we do.

In real life, people are constantly editing themselves. We leave things out, change the subject, pretend not to care, and say we’re fine when we clearly aren't. Even the people closest to us only get the version of ourselves we can communicate. And sometimes that version is a spectacularly poor representation.

Fiction, on the other hand, lets us cheat.

We get the thoughts people would never say aloud. We get their worst impulses, private embarrassments, and petty jealousies. We get to see what they meant when they said something completely different. A character can behave terribly, and somehow, three pages later, we’re defending them like they’ve been personally wronged.

Not because we think they’re right. Because we understand how they got there.

I find that distinction interesting. Understanding someone isn’t the same as excusing them, though people constantly confuse the two. You can recognize exactly why someone did something and still think it was awful.

Literature is particularly good at forcing us into that uncomfortable middle ground. It asks us to sit with people we might otherwise dismiss.

And occasionally, rather inconveniently, those people remind us of ourselves.

I don’t think I’ve ever finished a genuinely good book feeling entirely comfortable. The books that stay with me usually expose some thought or feeling I was perfectly happy keeping to myself. Something selfish, insecure, contradictory, or just a little ridiculous. It’s unsettling to discover that a fictional person has apparently been reading your diary.

There’s also a peculiar relief in it.

Maybe that’s what people mean when they say a book made them feel seen. Not that the author somehow knew them personally, but that something they assumed was uniquely theirs turned out to be part of a much larger human experience.

It’s almost disappointing, really. You spend years carefully developing your very specific collection of emotional problems, only to discover that somebody wrote about them in 1847.

And probably more eloquently.

But here’s the part I keep coming back to: we want other people to understand us in the same way we understand fictional characters, and I’m not convinced that’s possible.

A novel has the advantage of structure. Even when a character is complicated, their contradictions have been arranged for us. We can go back to chapter three and find the moment everything started going wrong. We can reread a conversation. We can see the difference between what someone said and what they were thinking.

Real people don’t come with footnotes explaining everything.

We meet each other in the middle of stories that started long before we arrived. We misunderstand things. We make assumptions. We remember the same conversation differently. And, unlike a novel, there’s no narrator quietly stepping in to explain what everyone actually meant.

Maybe that’s why being misunderstood can feel so frustrating. We know there’s more context. We know there are reasons. We know the version of ourselves somebody else has constructed is incomplete. Still, we can’t exactly hand them a four-hundred-page account of our internal lives and ask them to reconsider.

Although I can think of a few situations where I would have liked to.

I suppose the obvious conclusion is that we should all try harder to understand one another. Which is true, but also sounds suspiciously like the moral at the end of a children’s television episode.

I think there’s a less comforting conclusion, too.

Maybe nobody will ever understand us entirely. Maybe even the people who love us most will occasionally get it wrong. And maybe that’s not necessarily evidence that they don’t know us or care about us. It might just be an unavoidable part of being separate people.

That possibility is oddly reassuring.

We can spend so much time trying to make ourselves legible to other people that we forget we’re allowed to be complicated without explaining. Not every feeling needs to be translated into something sensible. Not every contradiction needs to be resolved.

And not every person needs access to the director’s commentary.

I still think there’s something wonderful about finding a character who seems to articulate a feeling you’ve never quite managed to explain. I love that a book written decades or centuries ago can make you feel briefly, impossibly understood.

But perhaps the real comfort of literature isn’t that it proves somebody, somewhere, understands us perfectly.

Perhaps it’s that it reminds us how many different ways there are to be human.

And that being difficult to explain doesn’t make us particularly unusual.

For someone who has spent a frankly unreasonable amount of time trying to explain herself, that's probably worth remembering.

Comments


bottom of page