top of page

Whatever Happened to Having Taste?

Writer: Brooke Morgan
Brooke Morgan
Oct 16
5 min read

I have a theory that we've become so obsessed with having good taste that we've forgotten how to actually have any.

And before anyone gets defensive, I'm including myself. I've absolutely looked at something, decided I liked it, and then wondered whether I only liked it because I'd seen it seventeen times on Pinterest. Which is a slightly humiliating thing to admit, but I suspect I'm not alone.

Somewhere along the way, having taste became less about knowing what you like and more about knowing what you're supposed to like.

There's a difference, and I think it's getting harder to tell.

Take personal style, for example. We're constantly being told to find our aesthetic, which sounds like a lovely exercise in self-discovery until you realize that most of the available options have already been named, categorized, photographed, and conveniently linked to an Amazon storefront.

You can be a clean girl, a downtown girl, a coastal grandmother, a mob wife, an old-money enthusiast, or whatever we're calling women who wear cardigans this week.

Apparently, simply owning clothes is no longer enough.

And the strangest part is that these aesthetics are presented as expressions of individuality. We're encouraged to discover our unique personal style by selecting from a collection of pre-existing personalities, complete with approved colour palettes, musical preferences, and furniture.

It's like being handed a menu and told to express yourself.

I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with aesthetics. People have always used clothing, music, art, and the things they surround themselves with to communicate something about who they are. Subcultures existed long before TikTok, and people have been borrowing from one another's style for centuries.

But something about how quickly an aesthetic can now be packaged, marketed, and replaced feels distinctly depressing.

One minute, everyone is obsessed with minimalist interiors and beige everything. The next, we're collectively rediscovering colour, clutter, and the apparently revolutionary idea of owning objects that mean something to us.

It's not that tastes change. Of course they do. We've started treating taste like a subscription service that needs updating every three months.

And I think the same thing is happening to our opinions.

We have more access to art, music, film, literature, and criticism than any generation before us. In theory, that should make us incredibly interesting people. We can discover obscure bands from the seventies, watch films made on the other side of the world, and read essays written by people whose experiences are completely different from our own.

Instead, we somehow keep arriving at the same conclusions.

The same five books are essential reading. The same films are underrated masterpieces. The same albums are suddenly classics because a fifteen-second clip went viral. And the same opinions circulate until they're repeated so many times they start to sound like facts.

I find this particularly noticeable with films.

There's a certain kind of movie that the internet has collectively decided is good, and another kind that it has decided is embarrassing to enjoy. You can practically predict someone's Letterboxd favourites based on which corner of the internet they spend their time in.

And while I love a good film discussion, I find the idea of watching something to form the "correct" opinion about it completely exhausting.

Sometimes a film is technically brilliant, and I never want to see it again. Sometimes a movie is objectively ridiculous, and I've watched it six times. I don't think those two things need reconciling.

I also don't think enjoying something automatically makes it good, or that recognizing something as good means you're obligated to enjoy it.

Both thoughts can exist at once. Remarkable, I know.

What bothers me isn't that other people influence people. That's inevitable, and honestly, it's often a good thing. Half the music I love exists in my life because somebody else introduced me to it. Taste has always been social.

The problem begins when influence becomes substitution.

We stop asking ourselves what we actually think because someone else has already supplied a perfectly acceptable answer.

And algorithms make that remarkably easy.

They're designed to recognize what holds our attention and give us more of it, which sounds convenient, until you consider that discovering something new often requires encountering something you wouldn't have chosen for yourself.

A recommendation algorithm can tell me what I'm likely to enjoy based on what I've enjoyed before. What it can't really account for is the possibility that I might become interested in something completely unexpected.

Or that I might dislike something everyone else loves.

Or, perhaps most importantly, that I might change my mind.

There's something wonderfully embarrassing about looking back at your old music taste, fashion choices, or favourite films. I think we're supposed to cringe at those things, but I've always found them strangely endearing.

At least you liked something enough to commit.

I would much rather look back at an old outfit and wonder what possessed me than realize I spent years dressing like an algorithm's idea of a twenty-year-old woman.

And I think that's what gets lost in all this talk about curating ourselves.

Real taste is often inconsistent. It's influenced by nostalgia, personal associations, strange little obsessions, and things we can't adequately explain. You can love an acclaimed literary novel and an objectively terrible reality television show. You can listen to classical music one morning and, that afternoon, a song you discovered on a 2014 Tumblr playlist.

You don't have to make those interests fit together into a coherent brand.

In fact, I think the people with the most interesting taste are usually the ones whose preferences don't make immediate sense.

They like things passionately, sometimes inexplicably, and don't particularly care whether those things communicate the right message.

Which is increasingly rare in a culture where everything we enjoy can become part of our public identity.

A favourite book isn't just a favourite book anymore. It's something to display. A playlist becomes an aesthetic. A film review becomes a chance to show how well you understand cinema. Even a bedroom can start to feel less like somewhere you live and more like evidence of a personality you've carefully assembled.

And I understand the temptation. There's something comforting about making yourself legible by knowing that the things you like fit into a recognizable category.

But I wonder how much we miss when we're so concerned with making our interests look good together.

Maybe the answer is embarrassingly simple.

Listen to the album before deciding whether it's cool. Read the book because the description interests you, not because it's sitting on everybody's bedside table. Wear something because you like how it looks, even if nobody has invented a name for it yet.

And perhaps allow yourself to have a genuinely unpopular opinion every once in a while.

Not for the sake of being different. Being deliberately contrarian is just another way of letting everyone else decide what you think.

But because having taste should involve making choices, getting things wrong, discovering something unexpected, and occasionally loving something that nobody else understands.

I don't want every book I read, song I play, or outfit I wear to make sense as part of a carefully curated identity.

I want to like things because I like them.

Which, apparently, has become a fairly radical position.

Comments


bottom of page